Locked out? Call 604-227-908324/7 emergency · Vancouver · Kitsilano · West End · East VanArrival window on the callNo hidden feesLicensed & insured Locked out? Call 604-227-908324/7 emergency · Vancouver · Kitsilano · West End · East VanArrival window on the callNo hidden feesLicensed & insured

Spare Car Key vs. All Keys Lost: Why Replacement Costs Differ in Vancouver

By Sam S. · Oct 10, 2026
Same car.Different job.

Making a spare while one key still works is a different job from restoring access and programming a key with nothing to copy, so the quotes differ.

Two drivers have the same car.

One wants a spare key. The other has lost the only working key.

Why might they receive different quotes?

Because the starting point changes the work. Making an additional key while one still works can be a different job from restoring access and programming a replacement with nothing available.

What Happens When You Still Have a Working Key?

The technician can assess the existing key and the vehicle before making an additional one.

Depending on the system, the job may include cutting a blade, programming electronics, and testing the finished key.

Our car key replacement service handles enquiries for both spare keys and all-keys-lost situations.

A Spare Still Needs to Be Correct

Having a working key does not make every blank or fob suitable.

The replacement must match the vehicle's requirements. A key that resembles the original is not enough; the functions need to be checked.

What Changes When Every Key Is Missing?

The technician may first need to gain authorized access to the vehicle, establish the required key information, and use a programming process suited to an all-keys-lost situation.

The exact steps vary by vehicle.

This is why "it's the same car" does not always mean "it's the same job."

Tell the Locksmith Whether the Car Is Locked

Access is part of the assessment. So are the vehicle location and any parkade restrictions.

Our automotive locksmith service can discuss the whole situation rather than quoting for a key alone.

How Does the Key Type Affect the Price?

A mechanical key, a transponder key, and a proximity fob involve different parts and functions.

A smart fob may also include a separate emergency blade. Ask whether the quote covers everything needed for the intended use.

The badge on the bonnet is not the only factor. Model year and key system matter too.

Compare the Complete Quotes

A low starting price is not useful if essential work is missing from it.

Ask each provider whether the quote includes:

  • The service call.
  • The key or fob.
  • Blade cutting where required.
  • Programming and testing.
  • After-hours charges, if applicable.
  • Tax.

Our locksmith pricing page provides a starting point for that conversation.

Compare Like With Like

Check whether the quotes cover the same type of part, the same functions, and similar warranty terms.

Also compare the practical arrangements. Will the work happen at the car, or do you need to transport it elsewhere?

Does Urgency Change the Quote?

Tell the provider whether you need help immediately or can arrange a daytime appointment.

For a missing-only-key situation that cannot wait, our emergency locksmith service can confirm availability and discuss the applicable charges.

For a spare, scheduling ahead may give you more flexibility.

When Should You Make a Spare?

While the existing key still works is a sensible time to ask.

That is especially worth considering if two people share the car or your only key is already damaged or unreliable.

Store the spare somewhere useful. Inside the locked car is a location with a fairly obvious weakness.

Get a Quote for Your Actual Vehicle

Call 604-227-9083 or book a planned key appointment.

Tell us the year, make, model, and whether a working key exists. Those details make the quote more meaningful than a general price for "one car key."

► Related

More Locksmith Reading.

Related services and guides for Vancouver homes, cars and businesses.

► Want a real number?

Quote for Your Car.

lınq Websites, bookings, dispatch, marketing for small businesses. LINQSYSTEM.COM Create yours →